prokopetz:

Random thought: I suspect the reason that most nerds are terrible at fantasy worldbuilding - and I’m absolutely including myself in this assessment - is that we have a tendency to impute agency to technology.

That is, when we look at historical examples of societal change or upheaval that are accompanied by a technological paradigm shift, we tend to analyse that upheaval as an obvious and inevitable consequence of that technology; the social and economic milieu surrounding the event is considered, if not irrelevant, then at least of secondary importance.

It’s like we’ve recognised the inadequacies of the Great Man theory of history, but rather than adopting a substantively different approach, we’ve simply subtracted the Great Man, resulting in a historiography in which new technologies spring fully formed from the aether and work their will upon the world’s stage, with no acknowledgment that technological paradigm shifts are at least as much products of the material conditions of their development as they are drivers of those conditions.

Then we turn around and attempt to imagine a fantastical world by asking a series of questions of the form “how would this particular magical ‘technology’ change society?“, when we should equally be asking: “what sort of society would develop this kind of magic in the first place?“

1. invizagoth liked this
2. telia-zeva liked this
3. xenobio2 reblogged this from xenobiologicalresearch
4. corishadowfang reblogged this from moonbow-ink
5. aathhirraa reblogged this from moonbow-ink
6. indigo-inkwell liked this
7. moonbow-ink reblogged this from elumish
8. theveiledmatron liked this
9. swords0827 liked this
10. erosenoire liked this
11. derharlekin reblogged this from 9thbutterfly
12. derharlekin liked this
13. 9thbutterfly reblogged this from kawuli
14. crapblog3000 liked this
15. riskfreesuperdeer liked this
16. sour-rocks reblogged this from prokopetz
17. satanaels-pride reblogged this from weissroseschnee
18. weissroseschnee reblogged this from arbitrary-wombat
19. arbitrary-wombat reblogged this from prokopetz
20. steeple333 liked this
21. fannishcodex liked this
22. minutefish reblogged this from lemonadesoda
23. crows-and-rats liked this
24. malaxis liked this
25. lemonadesoda reblogged this from plotdesigner
26. plotdesigner reblogged this from likegarlandroses
27. likegarlandroses reblogged this from transmanrichardstrand
28. readasaur liked this
29. thevoidisloudandwantsorangejuice liked this
30. yetitty liked this
31. 926xej-blog liked this
32. cloudprincesslady reblogged this from shinyflareon
33. tumblinbean reblogged this from lilybradbury
34. strangelonetree reblogged this from lilybradbury
35. lilybradbury reblogged this from prokopetz
36. insightfulquote liked this
37. nowthatyouareyoung liked this
38. quillsupmyass reblogged this from prokopetz
39. nutter-fudger reblogged this from prokopetz
40. nutter-fudger liked this
41. anehan reblogged this from lysapadin
42. arcadien reblogged this from clevergirlhelps
43. peacheatssmiley liked this
44. starry-thread liked this
45. steamingwonderland reblogged this from castella-rays
46. steamingwonderland liked this
47. castella-rays reblogged this from lysapadin
48. strigineserpent reblogged this from lysapadin
49. prokopetz posted this
50. Show more notesLoading...