Your professor will not be happy with you if he says the Stanford Prison Experiment shows human nature and you say it shows the nature of white middle class college-aged boys.
Like he will not be happy at all.
For real though. That experiment. Scary shit.
This reminds me of a discussion that I read once which said Lord of the Flies would have turned out a hell of a lot differently if it was a private school of young girls (who are expected to be responsible and selfless instead), or a public school where the children weren’t all from an inherently entitled, emotionally stunted social class (studies have shown that people in lower socioeconomic classes show more compassion for others).
Or that the same premise with children raised in a different culture than the toxic and opressive British Empire and it’s emphasis on social hierarchy and personal wealth and status.
And that what we perceive as the unchangable truth deep inside humanity because of things like Lord of the Flies and the Stanford Prison Experiment, is just the base truths about what happens when you remove any accountabilty controlling one social group with an overwhelming sense of entitlement and an inability to feel compassion.I will always reblog this.
I just wanna say that the Lord of the Flies was explicitly written about high-class private school boys to make this exact point. Golding wrote Lord of the Flies partially to refute an earlier novel about this same subject: The Coral Island by R.M. Ballantyne. Golding thought it was absolutely absurd that a bunch of privileged little shits would set up some sort of utopia, so his book shows them NOT doing that.
This is also generally true about most psychological experiments.
There’s an experiment called “The Ultimatum Game”. It goes something like this.
- Subject A is given an amount of money (Say, $100).
- Subject A must offer Subject B some percentage of that money.
- If Subject B accepts Subject A’s offer, both get the agreed upon amount of money. If Subject B refuses, no one gets any money.
The most common result was believed to be that people favored 50/50 splits. Anything too low was rejected; people wanted fairness. This was believed to be universal.
And then a researcher went to Peru to do the experiment with members of the indigenous Machiguenga population, and was baffled to find that the results were totally different.
Because, to the Machiguenga, refusing any amount of free money (even an unfair amount) was considered crazy.
So the researcher took his work on the road (to 14 other ‘small scale’ societies and tribes) , and to his shock found the results varied wildly depending on where the test was done.
In fact, the “universal” result? Was an outlier.
And that’s the problem. 96% percent of test subjects for psychological research come from 12% of the population. Stuff that we consider to be universal facts of human nature… even things like optical illusions, just… aren’t.
You can read an article about it here. But the crux of it is that psychology is plagued with confirmation bias, and people are shaped more by their environment than we realize.
What this has created tho is a medical system that centers the psychology of middle and upper class white men.
belitos liked this
tais0303 reblogged this from wamweisha
ba-ba-baker-street liked this
soundfanatic reblogged this from lavenderek
primelaughter liked this
clementine-sapphic liked this
looklikeafloweratlast liked this
kitteninacup reblogged this from arewetumbling
a-depressed-pos liked this
winkbeforethesly reblogged this from arewetumbling
wamweisha reblogged this from arewetumbling
wamweisha liked this
notsorryjuststupid liked this
i-am-random-let-me-fandom reblogged this from clatterbane
arewetumbling reblogged this from arewetumbling
criminalists liked this
rockindragonz reblogged this from niru13
emberkeelty liked this
yes-im-only-5ft1 liked this
niru13 reblogged this from skeletxnqueen
rubyvent reblogged this from siarven bow-hime reblogged this from epicallyweird
evanline01 reblogged this from rhetoricandlogic
radicalforms liked this
suschuch reblogged this from suck-my-ass-thetic
xsurviv0rx liked this
stardust-and-ash reblogged this from warlockofthewoods
xsurviv0rx reblogged this from poundpuppymama
ringoftheanscestors reblogged this from impr0bablezer0
memm-uh liked this
totallynotdead liked this
cosmosclover reblogged this from knitwool
poundpuppymama reblogged this from knitwool
pinaceae liked this
lunariafemme liked this
creedyandtheuniverse liked this
pishyforgayrights liked this christinasworld liked this
grrldivision reblogged this from earthlyfey
aimanonaboa reblogged this from igavethatbitchalink
alarajrogers reblogged this from abilitiesconsideredunnatural
mathemagician7 reblogged this from nebcondist1
daedric liked this
punk-rock-karen-carpenter reblogged this from knitwool
b0bri liked this
vampiretarot liked this
mycologicalsociety liked this
knitwool reblogged this from earthlyfey
earthlyfey reblogged this from wlwzone
- Show more notes
