mspaintadventureswiki:

ikimaru:

micaxiii:

alinajames:

ikimaru:

already replied

it’s Grandpa, not Jake, they’re 2 completely different people who grew up in different environments and had different lives as clearly shown in the canon story

hiveswap is a /prequel/ not a /sequel/

I think the point op is trying to make is that even tho they are the same person from different realities, they still grew up differently so there not really anything to feel about Jake having a wife, if you only care about the Jake that is not Grandpa.

they decided to call Grandpa, Jake, in Hiveswap, I mean I guess it makes sense to give them the same names but I wish they used at least Jacob or a whole diff name because this confusing

still Hiveswap IS A PREQUEL, check the wiki, it takes place in 1994, 15 whole years before the start of HS there is no way that can be Jake lol

tfw you try to have kids with a woman that doesn’t exist in your universe and when you’re not even born yet

nice try

also Grandpa had a completely different life and and grew up around diff people on top of being just another person in general, so it’s possible he ended up marrying a  woman, different people from differnt universes, I don’t see how there is even a point to this discussion

+ edit: the young “Roxy” shown in the pics is teen mom, it was said in one of the HS books‘s side notes she lived in the mansion for a while

Wiki mod here to make a personal addition to this post, there is plenty of evidence in Homestuck itself without referring to Hiveswap or extra-canonical sources such as Hussie’s commentary that characters have the same first names both sides of the scratch.

Saying there is “evidence” is kind of obtuse considering that Nanna outright states that her name is in fact Jane.

Additionally confusion over such matters is why we currently have an active proposal over at the wiki about renaming the guardian articles.